Contents
pdf Download PDF pdf Download XML
30 Views
6 Downloads
Share this article
Research Article | Volume 2 Issue 9 (November, 2025) | Pages 50 - 54
A Study Using Garrett Ranking Approach in The City of Kolkata on The Ranking of Select Fashion and Lifestyle Retail Outlets & Factors Shaping Customer Perception Pertaining to The Effectiveness of Fashion & Lifestyle Retail Outlets.
1
Assistant Professor in Commerce, Barrackpore Rastraguru Surendranath College, Kolkata, India
Under a Creative Commons license
Open Access
Received
Sept. 10, 2025
Revised
Sept. 25, 2025
Accepted
Oct. 18, 2025
Published
Nov. 6, 2025
Abstract

The lifestyle and fashion retail market in India is expanding rapidly, driven by reasons such as increased disposable incomes, urbanization, and a trend toward branded retail. In addition, several global enterprises are entering the market, and new technologies have been embraced to improve the shopping experience. The Indian lifestyle and fashion retail sector is extremely competitive, with renowned local brands and an expanding presence of foreign retailers. This rivalry is spurred by causes such as the expanding e-commerce industry, shifting consumer preferences, and continued infrastructure and logistics development. While increased rivalry poses issues for certain firms, it also provides opportunity for innovation and expansion throughout the sector. The fashion and retail business in Kolkata has risen significantly as a result of the establishment of fashion and retail outlet stores such as Pantaloons, Reliance Trends, Shoppers Stop, Westside, Max and Zudio. This survey aims to determine which fashion and retail outlets are most popular with Kolkata customers. Furthermore, this study seeks to identify the elements that impact Kolkata customers' perceptions regarding  the efficacy of fashion and lifestyle retail establishments.

Keywords
INTRODUCTION

The fashion and lifestyle retail industry in India is one of the most speedily expanding businesses, with rapid fashion leading the way. Flexible supply chains for ultra-value brands, as well as brand loyalty for premium goods, are key growth drivers. As Indian marketers aim to make an item or brand appealing to consumers by stressing its better quality and uniqueness, the market is projected to see a significant infusion of both global and Indian fashion & lifestyle retail names. The growth of multichannel commerce, which combines online and physical experiences, is also altering the business, with 60-65% of Indian customers selecting integrated shopping experiences.

 

A "fashion & lifestyle retail outlet" is a business that offers a variety of apparel, accessories, and occasionally home goods and other things, all under one brand or with a specific lifestyle concept in mind. It seeks to communicate a sense of ambitious living by linking the product with a specific lifestyle.

 

Kolkata is currently the seventh most populated city of India with a population of 14,035,959 in 2011 census having average literacy rate of 86.31% . It is also the 14th city in India in terms of Local Purchasing Power Index with Local Purchasing Power Index of 67.1 as per Numbeo . The fashion and retail business in Kolkata has greatly increased as a consequence of the creation of fashion and retail outlet stores such as Pantaloons, Reliance Trends, Shoppers Stop, Westside, Max, and Zudio. The principal reasons behind the growth of retail & fashion outlets in India can be attributed to factors like Fashion and Apparel Dominance, Increased Consumer Spending, Rise of Online Shopping, Investment in Textile Parks, Growth in Kids' Garment Manufacturing, Growth in Retail Leasing, Direct Selling Opportunities etc

 

Objectives of the study:

This study is taken up with a view to accomplish the following objectives:

  1. To find out how the customers rank the six large scale fashion & lifestyle retail outlets in Kolkata
  2. To find out the perception of the respondents regarding the factors affecting the effectiveness of retail outlets
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

The present study is carried out using both Primary & Secondary data.

The Primary data is collected using a structured questionnaire having 4 demographic & 2 research oriented questions.

  • Sampling methods: Convenience sampling.
  • Data collection period: April & May 2025
  • Sample Size: 268
  • Data Collection area : Kolkata including greater Kolkata
  • Data Analysis tools : Graphical Analysis using Excel & Garrett Ranking

 

The secondary data has been collected from books, journals, reports & related websites.

 

ANALYSIS OF DATA:

This study is carried out with the objective of finding out & ranking two aspects relating to fashion & lifestyle retail outlets in Kolkata.

 

These are

  1. To find out how the customers rank the six large scale fashion & lifestyle retail outlets in Kolkata
  2. To find out the perception of the respondents regarding the factors affecting the effectiveness of retail outlets

 

To find out the response to the two above, there were two Research Oriented questions in the questionnaire. The first question was “RANK THE FASHION & LIFESTYLE RETAIL OUTLETS IN KOLKATA FROM 1-6 WHERE 1 IS THE BEST & 6 IS THE LEAST GOOD IN TERMS OF YOUR OVERALL LIKING & CHOICE”

 

The response to this question is analysed for Garrett Ranking using the following steps

 

STEP 1:

A table is prepared to summarize how respondents have ranked their overall liking of six fashion & lifestyle retail outlets in Kolkata

 

(Table 1)

Here Option 1 - OP 1 is Pantaloons

OP 2 is Shoppers Stop

OP 3 is Westside

OP 4 is Reliance Trends

OP 5 is Max

OP 6 is Zudio

 

STEP 2:

The Percent positions are found out -

Using the formula:

100 (Rij–0.5)/ Nj,

Where Rij= Rank given to the ith factor by jth individual and

            Nj= Number of factors ranked by jth individual, the percent positions are found out.

For 1st Rank =  100 (1 - 0.5) / 6 = 8.33

For 2nd Rank =  100 (2 - 0.5) / 6 = 25

For 3rd Rank =  100 (3 - 0.5) / 6 = 41.67

For 4th Rank =  100 (4 - 0.5) / 6 = 58.33

For 5th Rank =  100 (5 - 0.5) / 6 = 75

For 6th Rank =  100 (6 - 0.5) / 6 = 91.67

 

STEP 3:

The Garrett Score is found out using the Percent Position using the Garrett Conversion Table:

Percent Position & Garrett Score

Rank

Percent Position

Garrett Score

1

8.33

77

2

25

63

3

41.67

54

4

58.33

46

5

75

37

6

91.67

23

(Table2)

 

STEP 4:

Finally, the following table is used to find out the final rank of the six factors (Fashion & Lifestyle Retail outlets in Kolkata)

 

(Table 3)

 

So, we conclude that the survey has led to the following ranks for preference of Fashion & Lifestyle Retail outlets in Kolkata:

Final Preference Rank As Per Garrett Ranking

Fashion & Lifestyle Retail outlets in Kolkata

1ST

PANTALOONS

2ND

RELIANCE TRENDS

3RD

SHOPPERS STOP

4TH

WESTSIDE

5TH

MAX

6TH

ZUDIO

 

(Table 4)

The second question was “RANK THE FACTORS THAT IMPACT CUSTOMER PERCEPTION REGARDING RETAIL STORE EFFICIENCY ON A SCALE OF 1-6 WHERE 1 IS THE MOST IMPORTANT FACTOR ACCORDING TO YOU & 6 IS THE LEAST IMPORTANT FACTOR”

 

The response to this question is analysed using the following steps

 

STEP 1:

A table is prepared to summarize how respondents have ranked the factors that impact their perception regarding fashion & retail store efficiency in Kolkata.

(Table 5)

Here Option 1 – OP 1 is Product Availability

OP 2 is Price Range, Discounts & offers

OP 3 is Staff availability & staff knowledge

OP 4 is Store Layout & easiness of finding stock

OP 5 is queue management & billing

OP 6 is Use of technology in store

STEP 2:

The Percent positions are found out

 

Using the formula:

100 (Rij–0.5)/ Nj,

Where Rij= Rank given to the ith factor by jth individual and

            Nj= Number of factors ranked by jth individual, the percent positions are found out.

 

For 1st Rank =  100 (1 - 0.5) / 6 = 8.33

For 2nd Rank =  100 (2 - 0.5) / 6 = 25

For 3rd Rank =  100 (3 - 0.5) / 6 = 41.67

For 4th Rank =  100 (4 - 0.5) / 6 = 58.33

For 5th Rank =  100 (5 - 0.5) / 6 = 75

For 6th Rank =  100 (6 - 0.5) / 6 = 91.67

 

STEP 3:

The Garrett Score is found out using the Percent Position using the Garrett Conversion Table:

Percent Position & Garrett Score

Rank

Percent Position

Garrett Score

1

8.33

77

2

25

63

3

41.67

54

4

58.33

46

5

75

37

6

91.67

23

 (Table 6)

 

STEP 4:

Finally, the following table is used to find out the final rank of the six factors that impact respondents’ perception regarding fashion & retail store efficiency in Kolkata

(Table 7)

So, we conclude that the survey has led to the following ranks of the six factors that impact respondents’ perception regarding fashion & retail store efficiency in Kolkata

 

Final Preference Rank As Per Garrett Ranking

Factors That Impact Respondents’ Perception Regarding Fashion & Retail Store Efficiency In Kolkata

1ST

PRODUCT AVAILABILITY

2ND

STAFF AVAILABILITY & KNOWLEDGE

3RD

STORE LAYOUT & EASE OF FINDING STOCK

4TH

PRICE, DISCOUNT & OFFERS

5TH

QUEUE MANAGEMENT & BILLING

6TH

USE OF TECHNOLOGY IN STORE

(Table 8)

CONCLUSION

The study is carried out with two specific objectives relating to customer perception regarding fashion & lifestyle retail outlets in Kolkata. It is seen that majority of the customers have considered Pantaloons to be the best retail outlet in Kolkata region. However a growing retail outlet under the Tata Group – Zudio, has been found to have ranked last among the selected outlets. Very reasonably the cause behind this ranking of retail stores can be attributed to the second finding of the study where respondents have ranked Product availability to be the most important factor and Price, Discount & offers as the fourth factor only. Actually Pantaloons is greatly known for its variety and Zudio is more known for price reasonability & great offers. Furthermore, the respondents in Kolkata city with urban background and choice for latest trends & variety have ranked factors like Product availability, staff availability & staff knowledge & store layout & ease of finding stock over Pricing & discount related factors.

REFERENCES
  1. Berman, B. (2010), Competing in Tough Times: Business Lessons from L.L. Bean, Trader Joe's, Costco, and Other World-Class Retailers, FT Press, Upper Saddle River, NJ.
  2. Berry (1996). “Retailers with a Future”, Marketing Management, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 36–46.
  3. Basu,R., Kalyan K. Guin, Kalyan Sengupta, (2014) "Do apparel store formats matter to Indian shoppers?", International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, Vol. 42(8), pp.698 – 716
  4. Khan, M. L. (2018). The impact of education level on sustainable fashion consumption. Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management, 22(2), 157-172.
  5. Kumar, V. &. (2000). The effects of store location on consumer choice. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 7(3), 167-176
  6. Mccormick, Helen & Cartwright, Jo & Perry, Patsy & Barnes, Liz & Lynch, Sam & Ball, Gemma. (2014). Fashion retailing - Past, present and future. Textile Progress. 46.
  7. McColl, J., & Moore, C. (2011). An exploration of fashion retailer own brand strategies. Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management, 15(1), 91-107.
  8. Memon (2006). “Garment Lifestyle Retailing Stores: Vis á Vis Impact of Private Labels: A Paradigm Shift”, The ICFAI Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 5, No. 3, pp. 54–69.
  9. Pani, A. and Sharma, M. (2012). Emerging trends in fashion marketing: a case study of apparel retailing in India. International Journal of Business and Management tomorrow, 2 (10).
  10. Prasad, G. Hari Shankar (2014) Factors Influencing Buying Behavior of a Selected Apparel Retailer’s Customers, Annual Research Journal of Symbiosis Centre for Management Studies, Pune Vol. 1, Januray 2013 – January 2014, pp. 41–55.
  11. Wagner, U. &. (2009). The impact of store location on fashion retail sales. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 16(2), 141-148.
Recommended Articles
Research Article
Rethinking Quality Signals: How Service Quality Components Shape Image, Value, and Alumni Loyalty in Indian B-Schools
Published: 06/11/2025
Research Article
Digital Transformation as A Catalyst for Business Model Innovation: Balancing Challenges and Opportunities
...
Published: 06/11/2025
Research Article
Neuromarketing Insights for Predicting Consumer Purchase Intent
...
Published: 06/11/2025
Research Article
The Rise of Fractional Employment: An Empirical Analysis of HR Challenges in Managing Part-Time Experts in Tech Startups
...
Published: 06/11/2025
© Copyright Asian Society of Management & Marketing Research (ASMMR)